“Sherlock” vs. “Elementary”

Benedict Cumberpatch vs Johnny Lee Miller“Sherlock” wins.

My point is I wanted to like “Elementary” more.  Seeing the later first, the Americanized Sherlock seemed to have all the elements (pardon) of the classic in modern times.  I appreciated Lucy Liu as Dr. Watson, a feminist achievement and more interesting relationship dynamic, I believed.  The CBS Sherlock’s disdain for recovery and 12 step meetings while conceding the necessity would be an amusing subplot.  Finally, I was not fan of the BBC’s  producer and writer Steven Moffat.  For reasons beyond the scope of this rant, am convinced his contribution to the reboot of “Doctor Who” hurt more than helped.

Then I saw the BBC’s “Sherlock,” which proves the idiom “God is in the Detail”.  Since its introduction in 2010 there have been only 10 episodes produced.  “Elementary” has had 48 episodes since its debut in 2011, and is constrained by the hour format with commercial breaks, along with a requirement to appeal to a mass audience for ratings.  It is surprising “Elementary” is even as good as it is.

After watching the first two seasons of “Sherlock” had to concede it is comparable to a main course, whereas “Elementary” is, at its best, an  appetizer or dessert.  More often it is a popcorn snack.


About Richard Evans

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Relating the Classics to Modern Life

Pick Wayne's Brain

I write liberal political song parodies because somebody has to.

The Neighborhood

telling the story from every vantage point

Sony Arouje

a programmer's log


Program Manager on the .NET team at Microsoft


Computer whisperer. 80/20 Thinker. Accelerated financial freedom designer. User of technology for automation and visualization. Lifestyle designer.

Taking the Short View

Short reviews on TV, films, books & anything and everything else

Art Attack

Discovering art in everything

Maintaining Marilyn's Memory

Family and Friends Remember

Living on Eastern Time

The Return of the Prodigal Wolverine


Measuring out my attempts at real life.


A fine WordPress.com site

Bookish Batz

Books! Books! Books! Book Reviews and Recommendations.

Just Melinda

my half-hearted attempts to blog


Actress. Songstress. Musician.


Personal accounts of my 27 months as a Peace Corps Volunteer in Cameroon.

Review Junky

Reviews, opinions and more!

"I've Got a Golden Ticket!"

Staying a positive business owner in a hectic economy and a few helpful tips along the way...

NonJersey Girl

The world according to a NonJersey Girl living in Jersey

Addicted to Media

my half-hearted attempts to blog

Are You Zhazha?

Parent, Worker, Runner, Person, Stuff - Yep, pretty much sums it up.

Tween There Done That

Tales from the front lines of parenting by Laurie Gelman

Your Daily Vegan

my half-hearted attempts to blog